Posted on: March 8, 2008 1:08 pm
Edited on: March 8, 2008 1:26 pm

Jose Reyes: Overrated???

There’s always a plentiful amount of players that have un-normal amount of talent that help their teams to the max, but aren’t the sharpest fantasy tools. This isn’t quite the case with what we’re talking about here, but similar. I’m here to talk about a phenomenal player named Jose Reyes. These words are coming from an extreme New York Mets nut, but, Jose Reyes is overrated! Yup! That’s right! I said Overrated. Here are Reyes’ stats from last year, and we will break them down:

                                                                             AVG: .281   HR: 12   RBI: 57  Runs: 119   SB: 78

When you look at his 2007 stats, is there really anything too significant other than his ample amounts of SBs and runs? No. His batting average is terrible for a leadoff hitter. His home runs are a let-down considering his total in ’06 and only drove in 57 RBIs. This is a drop from 81 to 57, a difference of 24. There are some leagues that don’t even include runs as a scoring category. With all that said, Reyes is all about the stolen bases, and in most cases, runs as well. Now, I could draft a player like Ichiro or Crawford in the 2nd or 3rd round to get similar if not slightly better overall numbers. With a player like that, I could spend my 1st round pick on a big bat. In this case I love David Wright. He has power and great speed. He is the complete package. If you didn’t see the name Jose Reyes there, would you draft a guy with these stats in the 1st round? No. But, with his great potential and young age, Reyes is an exception. But are these the stats you look for with a 2nd or 3rd overall pick? No, but with the potential talent level he has, 5th or 6th overall may be better. I already said I love David Wright, so, in my opinion, he is the best option for the 2nd overall pick with Hanley’s loss of Miguel Cabrera. I just don’t think that with his current stats, that Jose Reyes is a logical 2nd or 3rd overall pick, and remember I’m a Mets fan. Outside of fantasy, Reyes is a player that you would build a team around. He is exciting to watch and lifts the Mets like none other, but, in fantasy, I don’t think he’s quite at that level yet.

Category: MLB
The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or